State officials denied the town's request for an extension, putting pressure on the town board to finalize a spending plan on Friday. However,
a scheduled 2 p.m. emergency meeting was abruptly adjourned until 6 p.m. after the board failed to reach a quorum, sparking frustration among local residents.
"They never cease to amaze us in, I hate to say it, a negative way," one resident said following the delay.
"They had this in their hands for over five weeks, and the fact that they waited last minute for the fiscal year to end to get something finalized with our budget is just not acceptable," another resident added.
Councilwoman Jennifer Hebert was the only board member to attend the afternoon session. The town clerk read statements from Councilmembers Salvatore Ferro, Dave Bennardo, Theresa Mari and Town Supervisor Edmund Smyth—specifically citing statements from Lupinacci, Mari and Bennardo—who declined to attend.
"I chose not to attend the meeting on reading of the case law interpreting town section 62," one statement read, referencing a state law that requires two days' notice for special meetings.
Some homeowners criticized the explanation, arguing the board should have anticipated the delay earlier in the week.
"When they left this room on Tuesday evening, they should have right then declared notice for an emergency meeting. I'm sure they knew they might very well need that," a resident said.
At the center of the debate is a proposed budget featuring an 18% tax increase, which would cost the average taxpayer roughly $300 more per year. During a Tuesday meeting, Councilwoman Theresa Mari introduced more than three dozen amendments to the spending plan, though some or all of those changes were expected to be reversed.
"Mari was actually the one that came up with those amendments, so I would like to hear more about that process and how those came to be," a resident said.
Supervisor Edmund Smyth warned that rising expenses are forcing Huntington to dip into its financial reserves to cover deficits—a trajectory that could deplete the town's reserves by the third quarter of 2027.
"To ignore the financial reality that everything costs more—all it does is kick the can down the road," Smyth said. "We're going to be having this same conversation next October."
As of 10 p.m. Friday, town officials had still not reached a decision, risking a missed state deadline if a vote is not finalized by midnight.